The Asian Commercial Sex Scene  

Go Back   The Asian Commercial Sex Scene > For stuff you can't discuss with your Facebook Account > Local Massage Service Directory [NEW]

Notices

Local Massage Service Directory [NEW] Soothing Stress Relief Services for the Man on the Go!

User Tag List
1998, AwesomeGuy, baboon, Bingbing, Chris, Coco, dudu, ejectjoy, exchange123, Franco_Barsei, georgemagnum, Joanne, Kopiosteve, max_priest, oshkosh, OshkoshV, Panda, sammy1978, Shakyywayy, SMRTLTD, stiffness, Testmonkeylah, tummybird

Reply
 
Thread Tools
  #120961  
Old 04-03-2023, 02:27 PM
ShittyAss ShittyAss is offline
Little Samster~
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Somewhere out there
Posts: 3,573
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 58 Post(s)
My Reputation: Points: 10820 / Power: 63
ShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond repute
Re: TCSS thread "My favourite MASSAGE girls"

Quote:
Originally Posted by (bossy) View Post
It is still up to individual preference, I don't like heavy favour so vanilla is ok for me.

End of the day it is still better than 88 scams,high entry with zero facilities and called themselves 'spa'.
These days vanilla is way too crappy n trash.. I was ok with Vanilla all along. But nowadays is worst than Vanilla.

Nowadays, even when i touch the boobs, thousand of comments come out from these girls. Not even to mention kiss their boobs yet.

And Fk u SLG. Pls ask those sluts to even indicate they are full wrap up n no touching even of boobs on your portal. IF not stop your fake ads.

Its bloody turn off frankly. If just to lie down and for her to hj and having my hands tied to myself, i might as well go hot spa or G spa n i pcc myself.
__________________
Fav Retired joints@ ClubVanilla,HaruHaru,GeishaPlace,HaluHalu,
SpaOrange, JieLe, Mackenzie,M2,YHC,Fuji


Eat, Sleep and Enjoy Massage

摸的时候是滑的,抱的时候是香的,吃的时候是甜的

I keep my dick safe to chiong for another day and not to end it today. Chiong safely!

Chionging is for life.. not chiong for the moment and regret

I have not hit round 2 for points exchange...not actively into points exchanging. Will return when i have time.
____________________

Do not reply my comments or pm me for locations if you are a CLONE account. ANTI-CLONES
  #120962  
Old 04-03-2023, 02:31 PM
Marq Marq is offline
Samster
 
Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 1,041
Mentioned: 1 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 384 Post(s)
My Reputation: Points: 3374 / Power: 19
Marq has a reputation beyond reputeMarq has a reputation beyond reputeMarq has a reputation beyond reputeMarq has a reputation beyond reputeMarq has a reputation beyond reputeMarq has a reputation beyond reputeMarq has a reputation beyond reputeMarq has a reputation beyond reputeMarq has a reputation beyond reputeMarq has a reputation beyond reputeMarq has a reputation beyond repute
Re: TCSS thread "My favourite MASSAGE girls"

Quote:
Originally Posted by ShittyAss View Post
These days vanilla is way too crappy n trash.. I was ok with Vanilla all along. But nowadays is worst than Vanilla. I

But these days, even when i touch the boobs, thousand of comments come out from these girls. Not even to mention kiss yet.

Its bloody turn off frankly. If just to lie down and for her to hj and having my hands tied to myself, i might as well go hot spa or G spa n i pcc myself.
Yea, those that stand/sit at your legs there, where they are totally out of reach. No different from you watch porn on a screen and diy
__________________
Expired Post for Pts Return:
Geek

Waiting Power Recharge to Return
- esssinine, hamsapkwai, heng49, szczesny, oldboy69, kthan10, slicker69

Have up before
- danny888, Havanna Slicks, Socialsocial88, Rickey, WankJanice


- If I have yet to return your points, apologies, please PM me
  #120963  
Old 04-03-2023, 02:32 PM
Special Spawner Special Spawner is offline
Samster
 
Join Date: Nov 2004
Posts: 698
Mentioned: 4 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 212 Post(s)
My Reputation: Points: 1617 / Power: 20
Special Spawner has a brilliant futureSpecial Spawner has a brilliant futureSpecial Spawner has a brilliant futureSpecial Spawner has a brilliant futureSpecial Spawner has a brilliant futureSpecial Spawner has a brilliant futureSpecial Spawner has a brilliant futureSpecial Spawner has a brilliant futureSpecial Spawner has a brilliant futureSpecial Spawner has a brilliant futureSpecial Spawner has a brilliant future
Re: TCSS thread "My favourite MASSAGE girls"

Quote:
Originally Posted by U-Da-Man View Post
Actually I blame the sg customers just as much bro.

Perhaps sg's greying nation have also affected the customer pool - and everyone's libido. I remember some posts reflecting how "our objectives are different now". Perhaps silly, futile, non-physical pursuits of young MLs have replaced the wonderful orgasmic excitement of mind-blowing service providers like before. I'm not that young too, but thank god I'm still as horny as ever, and remain a 2-shot per session man.

Worse, there's also numerous posts admonishing and belittling others for not wanting to pay higher rates for a boring "cannot do this, cannot do that" 30something vanilla milf. Shocking.

All these "market forces" has unfortunately invited an influx of spoilt MLs to take advantage of the above customers. Oh the stories I hear.....

But I do see some hope. Bro Kopiosteve has recently listed out a few good attitude service providers that are pre-covid standards - like Xiao Qi, Tian Tian and 99. Of course there's also Tang Tang, Xi Xi and Xin Er. So don't be too despaired. Hopefully more of these will render boring vanillas outdated... or is this just a fool's hope. Lol.
As the saying goes, 'want cheap, want green, want big breast'.

I don't think the few bros here contributing to FRs actually has so much power to cause 'market forces'. End of the day, it's preferences for both the ML and customers. You sell orange only, then only orange lovers will come buy from you. Simple as that.

If ML is vanilla, and shitty service, very soon customers will switch and she cannot survive anyway. But if her service happened to touch all the right spots, then she will continue to thrive.

Attitude and service is important. I know of the Jap FL I visited in Japan, I have to hands up to their attitude and service. A 1 shot man like me actually got 2 shots done in 90 mins. And this is not because I wanted it, but she encouraged me, telling me there is still time for another shot, even though only 30 mins left, and started arousing me. All that for $300 plus singapore dollars.
  #120964  
Old 04-03-2023, 02:34 PM
ShittyAss ShittyAss is offline
Little Samster~
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Somewhere out there
Posts: 3,573
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 58 Post(s)
My Reputation: Points: 10820 / Power: 63
ShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond repute
Re: TCSS thread "My favourite MASSAGE girls"

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dieheart View Post
Vanillas will provide extras to certain selected ones, to keep them as regulars. Some of the criteria for selection include amount of tips given, hygiene and how you treat the ML etc.

This is what is keeping the vanillas here for the longer term.
Then wtf are they posting fake contents in this case on their ads? I was never calculative with them and i tip them mostly.

Next time i will open their ad, show them what they post on ad and ask them to do it one by one.

They missed one item, i will spam them instantly. Give me poor feedback on their so called data base is useless because i tips girls.

These so called vanilla need to be taught a lesson.
__________________
Fav Retired joints@ ClubVanilla,HaruHaru,GeishaPlace,HaluHalu,
SpaOrange, JieLe, Mackenzie,M2,YHC,Fuji


Eat, Sleep and Enjoy Massage

摸的时候是滑的,抱的时候是香的,吃的时候是甜的

I keep my dick safe to chiong for another day and not to end it today. Chiong safely!

Chionging is for life.. not chiong for the moment and regret

I have not hit round 2 for points exchange...not actively into points exchanging. Will return when i have time.
____________________

Do not reply my comments or pm me for locations if you are a CLONE account. ANTI-CLONES
  #120965  
Old 04-03-2023, 02:40 PM
ShittyAss ShittyAss is offline
Little Samster~
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Somewhere out there
Posts: 3,573
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 58 Post(s)
My Reputation: Points: 10820 / Power: 63
ShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond reputeShittyAss has a reputation beyond repute
Re: TCSS thread "My favourite MASSAGE girls"

Quote:
Originally Posted by Special Spawner View Post
As the saying goes, 'want cheap, want green, want big breast'.

I don't think the few bros here contributing to FRs actually has so much power to cause 'market forces'. End of the day, it's preferences for both the ML and customers. You sell orange only, then only orange lovers will come buy from you. Simple as that.

If ML is vanilla, and shitty service, very soon customers will switch and she cannot survive anyway. But if her service happened to touch all the right spots, then she will continue to thrive.

Their biz will not be affected. Thanks to the lousy scene of sg massage caused by useless AV.

U avoid it, there will be a next guy to visit. Never lack of customer from forum.

And my comment on vanilla doesnt mean i need to FN n dig n kiss until no day no light.

These days vanilla u touch the boobs, full of stupid comment that is bloody turn off.

Now there should be another category worst than Vanilla. Is called the UNTOUCHABLE.

Its not abt hw many times u visit them or got chem or no chem or got tips or no tips.

Its about they dun even allow u to touch at all. And my touch isnt about grabbing like no tmr as well.
__________________
Fav Retired joints@ ClubVanilla,HaruHaru,GeishaPlace,HaluHalu,
SpaOrange, JieLe, Mackenzie,M2,YHC,Fuji


Eat, Sleep and Enjoy Massage

摸的时候是滑的,抱的时候是香的,吃的时候是甜的

I keep my dick safe to chiong for another day and not to end it today. Chiong safely!

Chionging is for life.. not chiong for the moment and regret

I have not hit round 2 for points exchange...not actively into points exchanging. Will return when i have time.
____________________

Do not reply my comments or pm me for locations if you are a CLONE account. ANTI-CLONES
  #120966  
Old 04-03-2023, 02:45 PM
Ahfai Ahfai is offline
Samster
 
Join Date: Jan 2023
Posts: 71
Mentioned: 7 Post(s)
Tagged: 1 Thread(s)
Quoted: 65 Post(s)
My Reputation: Points: 240 / Power: 2
Ahfai is a Helpful and Caring SamsterAhfai is a Helpful and Caring SamsterAhfai is a Helpful and Caring Samster
Re: TCSS thread "My favourite MASSAGE girls"

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ninja_Assassin View Post
She will offer to you.... up to you whether to take it up.
Does natalie let you touch her boobs or suck them?
  #120967  
Old 04-03-2023, 02:47 PM
future96 future96 is offline
Samster
 
Join Date: Jan 2014
Posts: 164
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 33 Post(s)
My Reputation: Points: 1574 / Power: 11
future96 has a brilliant futurefuture96 has a brilliant futurefuture96 has a brilliant futurefuture96 has a brilliant futurefuture96 has a brilliant futurefuture96 has a brilliant futurefuture96 has a brilliant futurefuture96 has a brilliant futurefuture96 has a brilliant futurefuture96 has a brilliant futurefuture96 has a brilliant future
Talking Re: TCSS thread "My favourite MASSAGE girls"

Quote:
Originally Posted by ShittyAss View Post
These days vanilla is way too crappy n trash.. I was ok with Vanilla all along. But nowadays is worst than Vanilla.

Nowadays, even when i touch the boobs, thousand of comments come out from these girls. Not even to mention kiss their boobs yet.

And Fk u SLG. Pls ask those sluts to even indicate they are full wrap up n no touching even of boobs on your portal. IF not stop your fake ads.

Its bloody turn off frankly. If just to lie down and for her to hj and having my hands tied to myself, i might as well go hot spa or G spa n i pcc myself.
No zhut zhut maybe can understand, but no touching of boobs? Then what for list on an explicit website with erotic photos
__________________
please don’t zap me if I said something wrong
  #120968  
Old 04-03-2023, 02:49 PM
qwertysbfsg qwertysbfsg is offline
Samster
 
Join Date: Nov 2022
Posts: 269
Mentioned: 5 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 247 Post(s)
My Reputation: Points: 620 / Power: 2
qwertysbfsg is a name known to allqwertysbfsg is a name known to allqwertysbfsg is a name known to allqwertysbfsg is a name known to allqwertysbfsg is a name known to allqwertysbfsg is a name known to all
Re: TCSS thread "My favourite MASSAGE girls"

Quote:
Originally Posted by ShittyAss View Post
Their biz will not be affected. Thanks to the lousy scene of sg massage caused by useless AV.

U avoid it, there will be a next guy to visit. Never lack of customer from forum.

And my comment on vanilla doesnt mean i need to FN n dig n kiss until no day no light.

These days vanilla u touch the boobs, full of stupid comment that is bloody turn off.

Now there should be another category worst than Vanilla. Is called the UNTOUCHABLE.

Its not abt hw many times u visit them or got chem or no chem or got tips or no tips.

Its about they dun even allow u to touch at all. And my touch isnt about grabbing like no tmr as well.
Almost all vanillas (those that offer only HJ in their ads) that I have visited allowed touching of their boobs leh. However, only about one third generously offered them for zhut zhut (e.g. Nina, Yi Yi and Fairy and the delisted Rayna, Lin Lin and Angel). Maybe the heavily flavoured ones are better.
  #120969  
Old 04-03-2023, 03:05 PM
kaixin82 kaixin82 is offline
Samster (Donor)
 
Join Date: Sep 2018
Posts: 141
Mentioned: 2 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 49 Post(s)
My Reputation: Points: 1702 / Power: 18
kaixin82 has a brilliant futurekaixin82 has a brilliant futurekaixin82 has a brilliant futurekaixin82 has a brilliant futurekaixin82 has a brilliant futurekaixin82 has a brilliant futurekaixin82 has a brilliant futurekaixin82 has a brilliant futurekaixin82 has a brilliant futurekaixin82 has a brilliant futurekaixin82 has a brilliant future
Re: TCSS thread "My favourite MASSAGE girls"

Name the untouchable lah.
If not, how is she going to improve?
  #120970  
Old 04-03-2023, 03:05 PM
Dieheart Dieheart is offline
Samster
 
Join Date: Feb 2023
Posts: 63
Mentioned: 1 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 47 Post(s)
My Reputation: Points: 150 / Power: 2
Dieheart is a Helpful and Caring SamsterDieheart is a Helpful and Caring Samster
Quote:
Originally Posted by ShittyAss View Post
Then wtf are they posting fake contents in this case on their ads? I was never calculative with them and i tip them mostly.

Next time i will open their ad, show them what they post on ad and ask them to do it one by one.

They missed one item, i will spam them instantly. Give me poor feedback on their so called data base is useless because i tips girls.

These so called vanilla need to be taught a lesson.
What I meant are those who provide extras outside the menu to selected ones.

Each of the selected ones will think that they are the only one. He will cling onto her.

Personally, I haven't met one who does not allow touching of boobs.
  #120971  
Old 04-03-2023, 03:36 PM
lacoruna69's Avatar
lacoruna69 lacoruna69 is offline
Samster
 
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Sinkapore
Posts: 2,375
Mentioned: 3 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 486 Post(s)
My Reputation: Points: 3348 / Power: 21
lacoruna69 has a reputation beyond reputelacoruna69 has a reputation beyond reputelacoruna69 has a reputation beyond reputelacoruna69 has a reputation beyond reputelacoruna69 has a reputation beyond reputelacoruna69 has a reputation beyond reputelacoruna69 has a reputation beyond reputelacoruna69 has a reputation beyond reputelacoruna69 has a reputation beyond reputelacoruna69 has a reputation beyond reputelacoruna69 has a reputation beyond repute
Re: TCSS thread "My favourite MASSAGE girls"

Quote:
Originally Posted by ShittyAss View Post
These days vanilla is way too crappy n trash.. I was ok with Vanilla all along. But nowadays is worst than Vanilla.

Nowadays, even when i touch the boobs, thousand of comments come out from these girls. Not even to mention kiss their boobs yet.
Chill, Bro.

Ever since this covid started, things have changed.

The MLs are not foolish, who wouldn't want to do less but get more $?

Personally, I avoid all those vanillas (even during pre covid). No matter how good FRs are.

I only go for FN. If the ad hilight Nude Massage in red, I expect them to strip full. If they still in underwear, I only let them wear until massage.

When sensual starts, I politely asked them to remove.

Btw, it will be kind of you to indicate who are those who refuse to let you touch their boobs. So I can avoid.

Don't be surprised. some FN ones for some reason don't allow me to touch their boobs....citing want to come auntie liao, so pain pain.
__________________
'If you want to know how a future wife is going to treat you, observe how she treats members of her own family and how she interacts with the less fortunate of society'

Up List - vampy;witan788;BAD-MAN;Feiji;skyhawk958;peterfish;wolverman;~oyster~;
  #120972  
Old 04-03-2023, 03:43 PM
SaintTKP SaintTKP is offline
Samster
 
Join Date: Mar 2014
Posts: 648
Mentioned: 7 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 482 Post(s)
My Reputation: Points: 1601 / Power: 11
SaintTKP has a brilliant futureSaintTKP has a brilliant futureSaintTKP has a brilliant futureSaintTKP has a brilliant futureSaintTKP has a brilliant futureSaintTKP has a brilliant futureSaintTKP has a brilliant futureSaintTKP has a brilliant futureSaintTKP has a brilliant futureSaintTKP has a brilliant futureSaintTKP has a brilliant future
Bro lacoruna69

For all the FN MLs you have tried, what is your minimum you expect them to let you do? Touch pussy? Rub pussy? Dig pussy?

Is there a "miminum expectation" for full nude MLs?

Quote:
Originally Posted by lacoruna69 View Post
Chill, Bro.

Ever since this covid started, things have changed.

The MLs are not foolish, who wouldn't want to do less but get more $?

Personally, I avoid all those vanillas (even during pre covid). No matter how good FRs are.

I only go for FN. If the ad hilight Nude Massage in red, I expect them to strip full. If they still in underwear, I only let them wear until massage.

When sensual starts, I politely asked them to remove.

Btw, it will be kind of you to indicate who are those who refuse to let you touch their boobs. So I can avoid.

Don't be surprised. some FN ones for some reason don't allow me to touch their boobs....citing want to come auntie liao, so pain pain.
  #120973  
Old 04-03-2023, 04:11 PM
Mobile88 Mobile88 is offline
Samster
 
Join Date: Jul 2022
Posts: 508
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 573 Post(s)
My Reputation: Points: 1280 / Power: 2
Mobile88 has much to be proud ofMobile88 has much to be proud ofMobile88 has much to be proud ofMobile88 has much to be proud ofMobile88 has much to be proud ofMobile88 has much to be proud ofMobile88 has much to be proud ofMobile88 has much to be proud ofMobile88 has much to be proud of
Re: TCSS thread "My favourite MASSAGE girls"

I do think the vanillas make good money at the start because of SBF reviews.
Like seriously some are too busy to even reply once the hype for her is there. Our FR does have an impact for the forum and the many lurkers out there here for it. Especially when FR constantly promotes RTM for 6/10 7/10 sort
Then the MLs will be encouraged to share with their friends that this is now the norm because many customers.

Probably attracting previous MLs to return too. I’m sure they have ways to share their gossips as much as us having a forum. So then promoting the influx of more vanillas.
For the vanillas that remained so, probably leave SG after business slowed down a lot even though after regulars still visit. This was my discovery when previous a ML was super hyped here. Like bros can’t get a slot at all. When I visit her much later, she claim only having 2 customer that day. And I wasn’t sure why she was in the hype previously also. Like super normal standard ML
  #120974  
Old 04-03-2023, 04:21 PM
Ahfai Ahfai is offline
Samster
 
Join Date: Jan 2023
Posts: 71
Mentioned: 7 Post(s)
Tagged: 1 Thread(s)
Quoted: 65 Post(s)
My Reputation: Points: 240 / Power: 2
Ahfai is a Helpful and Caring SamsterAhfai is a Helpful and Caring SamsterAhfai is a Helpful and Caring Samster
Re: TCSS thread "My favourite MASSAGE girls"

Anyone can tell me if this one is okay? i confused lol

https://sgbeautycastle-24.com/natalie-nuru-massage-hj/, is it same natalie as in sglonelyguy?
  #120975  
Old 04-03-2023, 04:34 PM
Marq Marq is offline
Samster
 
Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 1,041
Mentioned: 1 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 384 Post(s)
My Reputation: Points: 3374 / Power: 19
Marq has a reputation beyond reputeMarq has a reputation beyond reputeMarq has a reputation beyond reputeMarq has a reputation beyond reputeMarq has a reputation beyond reputeMarq has a reputation beyond reputeMarq has a reputation beyond reputeMarq has a reputation beyond reputeMarq has a reputation beyond reputeMarq has a reputation beyond reputeMarq has a reputation beyond repute
Re: TCSS thread "My favourite MASSAGE girls"

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ahfai View Post
Anyone can tell me if this one is okay? i confused lol

https://sgbeautycastle-24.com/natalie-nuru-massage-hj/, is it same natalie as in sglonelyguy?
You also funny...... If you know the nat that everyone is talking about is from sgl, why are you not looking at the one at sgl?

Its like people talking about a chicken rice stall, and you go to a duck rice stall and ask if this is the same one......
__________________
Expired Post for Pts Return:
Geek

Waiting Power Recharge to Return
- esssinine, hamsapkwai, heng49, szczesny, oldboy69, kthan10, slicker69

Have up before
- danny888, Havanna Slicks, Socialsocial88, Rickey, WankJanice


- If I have yet to return your points, apologies, please PM me
Advert Space Available
Bypass censorship with https://1.1.1.1

Cloudflare 1.1.1.1
Reply



Bookmarks

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off


t Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
TCSS thread "My favourite FJ girls" HornyGDragon FL Dome 2 - The Middle Kingdom Spreads its Wings 1 09-09-2014 05:18 PM
what happen to tcss my fav girls thread? xentric FL Dome 2 - The Middle Kingdom Spreads its Wings 2 29-05-2014 08:21 PM
TCSS thread "My favourite Girls" locked? funtimesarehere FL Dome 2 - The Middle Kingdom Spreads its Wings 1 12-01-2014 06:15 PM


All times are GMT +8. The time now is 02:37 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.10
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
Copywrong © Samuel Leong 2006 ~ 2023 ph